Getting help with your digital marketing should make your life easier, not more stressful. And those leads should turn into sales. Wondering if the money you’re putting into campaigns is actually paying off can be stressful.

You’re not alone. A lot of people feel this, especially when they’re working with an agency that doesn’t have the right reporting in place.

Too often, agencies make things confusing with jargon and endless spreadsheets. That’s a lot to wrap your head around, which is exactly why you hired someone to help in the first place. 

You deserve transparency and the full picture. Clear reporting is key so you can see what’s working and where your dollars are going. But what does that really look like?

Here’s a list of questions to ask your agency to make sure your lead generation efforts are actually delivering quality results.

Before you talk numbers, you and your agency need to agree on what a meaningful lead actually is. A qualified lead should match your goals, not a generic definition.

Ask your agency to outline the actions or behaviors that count as a strong lead for your business. 

For example, does a qualified lead look like:

• Someone who simply visited a page? 
• Someone who filled out a form? 
• Someone who’s had multiple interactions with your brand?

A good agency should give you a clear, detailed definition so you’re not chasing vanity metrics or inflated lead counts.

Once you know what a lead is, you need to understand how your agency follows that lead through the full customer journey.

Ask them to walk you through:

Where your leads come from

You should be able to see which leads came from organic search, paid search, paid social, email, or other channels, and how each channel performs differently.

What metrics they prioritize

Every business looks at different indicators. Make sure your agency focuses on metrics that you agree matter:

• Reach for awareness
• CTR for user interest
• CPC for cost efficiency
• Conversions for bottom-line performance

What’s tracked on your website

You should be able to see how people behave once they land on your site. Are they clicking key pages? Completing conversion events? Taking actions that show real intent?

Clear, accurate tracking gives you visibility into what’s working, what isn’t, and where your budget is actually making an impact.

Reporting and ROI

The right tools make all the difference when it comes to understanding where your leads are coming from and what’s actually driving results. Ask your agency what tracking tools they use and why it matters. 

For example, an agency might use Google Analytics to see how visitors interact with your website, Google Tag Manager to track specific actions, or platforms like LeadsRX to connect leads to the campaigns that brought them in. 

These tools give you a clear picture of what’s working and help your agency optimize for campaign performance.

Quantity doesn’t always mean quality. Even if your campaigns bring in a lot of leads, they won’t help your business if they aren’t the right fit.

Ask your agency how they make sure the leads are:

• Actually interested in your products or services
• Likely to convert, based on engagement signals like time on site, key actions, or bounce rate

A good strategy focuses on attracting the right people, not just more people.

Digital Marketing Agency Horror Stories and How to Prevent Them

Lead generation is just the first step. Once someone’s in your system, what happens next?

• Are they getting helpful, timely emails?
• Are you retargeting them with relevant ads? 
• How do you keep them engaged until they’re ready to buy?

Strong lead nurturing turns warm leads into actual customers.

Email Marketing

More Than an Agency. Your Marketing Ally.

Partnering with the right digital marketing agency can transform your lead generation. Like any good relationship, it works best when you are on the same page. The right agency will be transparent, focused, and ready to deliver real results.

Got more questions about lead tracking or digital lead generation? Let’s chat!

ASK ABOUT A FREE PROPOSAL »